Showing posts with label Equitable Distribution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Equitable Distribution. Show all posts

Sunday, May 12, 2024

Discovery, certiorari, mandamus, foreign subpoena, and buckwheat crepes with prosciutto, arugula, and asiago

 

Civil procedure -- Discovery -- Cellphone data -- Forensic review -- Appeals -- Certiorari -- Trial court departed from essential requirements of the law by requiring a forensic expert to make a complete copy of the entire contents of petitioner's cellphone to be reviewed by petitioner's attorney where respondent failed to establish that there was any actual or threatened alteration, deletion, or destruction of data on petitioner's cellphone, and no less intrusive means to obtain the information sought -- Petitioner has a reasonable expectation of privacy in contents of her cellphone and, as such, there needed to be an appropriate showing by respondent and a proper balancing of competing interests by trial court -- Requiring the imaging and production of the entire contents of one's cellphone cannot be justified merely because it is the quickest and most efficient method to obtain the discovery sought -- Fact that order required disclosure to petitioner's own attorney was insufficient, without more, to protect petitioner's privacy rights. ELIZABETH ROQUE, Petitioner, v. LEWIS SWEZY, et al., Respondents. 3rd District.

Civil procedure -- Discovery -- Foreign subpoena -- Enforcement -- Jurisdiction -- Louisiana subpoena commanding a non-party Florida resident to produce documents -- Trial court erred by denying plaintiff's motion to compel production of items listed in a domesticated Louisiana subpoena duces tecum and deferring to Louisiana court on issue of whether information requested in subpoena was discoverable -- Under the Uniform Interstate Depositions and Discovery Act, the decision of whether to enforce a domesticated subpoena or a protective order based upon a Florida witness's objections is to be made by the discovery state's court -- Remand for trial court to rehear plaintiff's motion to compel and the witness's motion for protective order, and conduct an independent determination of whether the information requested in the plaintiff's subpoena is discoverable. LUV N CARE, LTD., Appellant, v. LISA HAKIM, et al., Appellees. 4th District.

Civil procedure -- Dismissal -- Sanction -- Failure to obtain counsel -- Notice and opportunity to be heard -- Trial court violated plaintiff's due process rights when it granted defendant's motion to dismiss action for failure to obtain successor counsel within time period ordered by trial court where trial court's order contained no express language placing plaintiff on notice that its failure to obtain counsel within designated time could result in dismissal -- Furthermore, plaintiff had no reasonable notice or meaningful opportunity to be heard in response to defendant's motion to dismiss where motion was not noticed for hearing and order on the motion was entered twenty-five hours after motion was filed. BABCOCK NEW HAVEN, LLC, Appellant, v. VAHEED TEIMOURI and TEIMOURI & ASSOCIATES, INC., Appellees. 5th District.

Condominiums -- Dispute between unit owners -- Attorney's fees -- Prevailing party -- Voluntary dismissal -- Trial court abused its discretion in denying defendants' motion to tax attorney's fees as prevailing parties under section 718.303 after plaintiff voluntarily dismissed action based on determination that there was minimal litigation -- General rule that a defendant is a prevailing party when a plaintiff voluntarily dismisses an action applies even where there is limited pre-trial activity prior to dismissal -- No exceptions to general rule were applicable where defendants did not pay any of the damages sought and their actions did not render the lawsuit moot. LEENA MARGIT VILER f/k/a LEENA MARGIT SILVAST and GIORDANO G. VILER, Appellants, v. UNIVERSAL PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY a/s/o JAMES P. LAMANNA, Appellee. 4th District.

Contracts -- Insurance -- Settlement agreement -- Enforcement -- Trial court erred by granting defendants' motion to enforce settlement agreement where plaintiff's offer to settle expressly stated that it was contingent on defendant's insurer's verification that there were no other policies which may have provided coverage for underlying automobile accident, and an additional policy held by a codefendant was disclosed after acceptance of the settlement offer -- Request to insurer for information on any known policies was an essential term of plaintiff's offer to settle with which defendant's insurer failed to comply. PEDRO FUNDORA, etc., Appellant, v. ROBERTO DANGOND, et al., Appellees. 3rd District. 

Counties -- Contracts -- Dismissal -- Limitation of actions -- Continuing breach doctrine -- Contract requiring defendant to redevelop property pursuant to a master plan that had to be submitted and approved by the county -- Trial court erred in granting motion to dismiss with prejudice based on conclusion that, because more than five years had passed since date master plan was required to be submitted to county, the statute of limitations for bringing action on written contract had expired -- Complaint does not conclusively show that the statute of limitations bars action where complaint alleged various breaches of contract regarding defendant's failure to complete the redevelopment of real property that related not only to defendant's single act of failing to submit master plan by the designated date, but also in failing to comply with numerous other intertwined, ongoing, and continuing contractual duties and obligations that postdated the date that the master plan was due. HERNANDO COUNTY, FLORIDA, Appellant, v. HERNANDO COUNTY FAIR ASSOCIATION, INC., Appellee. 5th District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Equitable distribution -- Marital/nonmarital assets -- Trial court erred in failing to credit wife with marital funds used to pay down mortgage on husband's nonmarital property on the ground that the property actually depreciated in value during marriage -- Any increase in property's equity resulting from payments made with marital funds is a marital asset subject to equitable distribution. NADJA MARCELA BAZAN VASSALLO, Appellant, v. EDELMO ESCALONA SOCARRAS, Appellee. 3rd District.

Estates -- Assets -- Limited liability companies -- Dissolution -- Real property held by LLC wholly owned by decedent -- Trial court erred in denying motion seeking determination that real property was not an estate asset based on trial court's determination that the LLC's assets were assets of the estate because the single-member LLC immediately dissolved upon decedent's death -- Death of sole member does not immediately dissolve a single-member LLC -- Not until ninety days after decedent's death, which was well after denial of motion to determine assets, did the death become an event causing dissolution under relevant statutes -- Furthermore, LLC must be dissolved by filing articles of dissolution, after which LLC still continues for certain purposes such as winding up. PRECIOUS EZEAMAMA, Appellant, v. IN RE: THE ESTATE OF CATHERINE EZEAMAMA CHIBUGO, Appellee. 3rd District.

Liens -- Construction lien -- Discharge -- Mandamus -- Petition seeking to compel trial court to discharge a subcontractor's construction lien pursuant to section 713.21(4) is denied -- Section 713.21 only applies to a lien that is properly perfected -- Because complaint specifically alleged subcontractor had failed to perfect its lien by serving a notice to property owner and therefore had no lien rights, petitioners could not avail themselves of the special statutory procedure authorized by section 713.21(4). ABRAHAM A. CALIXTE and DOROTHY DROUILLARD a/k/a DOROTHY CALIXTE, Petitioners, v. COASTAL BUILDING CONTRACTORS, LLC, Respondent. 4th District.

 The Law Lady.  For more info about us, click here.  To be added to our email circulation with MUCH, MUCH more law, click here and specify whether you wish to be added to our CRIMINAL, CIVIL, or  FEDERAL Recent Decisions of Interest.

Thursday, January 5, 2023

Punitive damages, attorney's fees, dissolution of marriage, and porchetta and basil pesto roll

 Attorney's fees -- Charging lien -- Error to deny motion to adjudicate and enforce charging lien against client's settlement funds based on determination that counsel had not established third element of charging lien, which requires an attempt to avoid the payment of fees or a dispute as to the amount involved, because the disagreement over amount owed was not between counsel and client, but rather between counsel and co-counsel from a different firm who was responsible for disbursing payments to creditors -- Client's failure to pay all that he owed counsel was enough to make prima facie showing of third element of charging lien -- Furthermore, co-counsel, who was client's lawyer and agent, did expressly act to withhold client's funds from counsel, client knew about it, and client appears to have done nothing about it -- Regardless of whether client's actions or inaction are attributable to client individually or to him as the principal responsible for his agent's conduct in regard to the settlement funds, the third element of a charging lien was satisfied -- Court rejects argument that money in co-counsel's trust account was no longer client's concern after client signed closing statement. LINDA COMMONS, ESQ. Appellant, v. JAMES SPRACKLEN; ECONOMY DENTURES OF HUDSON, L.L.C.; ROBERT P. MOFFETT, D.D.S.; ECONOMY DENTURES, INC., d/b/a One Day Dentures; LEROY POLITE, DMD.; and LEROY POLITE D.M.D., P.A., Appellees. 2nd District.

 

Attorney's fees -- Prevailing party -- Where former employer filed action against former employee alleging breach of non-compete agreement and non-solicitation agreement, seeking damages in one count and injunctive relief in another count, and subsequently filed amended complaint which dropped the claim for injunctive relief, former employee was entitled to award of attorney's fees as prevailing party in the initial action which was voluntarily dismissed -- Trial court erred in finding that claim for fees was not preserved in subsequent settlement agreement. STEVEN CASTO, Appellant, v. FIRST COAST CARDIOVASCULAR INSTITUTE, P.A., Appellee. 1st District.

 

Attorney's fees -- Proposal for settlement -- Ambiguities -- Defendant's proposal for settlement and release were clear and unambiguous notwithstanding supposed conflicting provisions in proposal and typographical error in general release consisting of use of an asterisk in place of the defendant's name -- Proposal and release stated with particularity relevant conditions and all non-monetary terms, and read as a whole, there were no ambiguities that could have reasonably affected plaintiff's decision whether to accept proposal -- Trial court erred by declining to enforce proposal for settlement. PUBLIX SUPER MARKETS, INC., Appellant, v. SIERRA ALFORD, Appellee. 5th District.

 

Child custody -- Decision-making authority -- Parenting plan -- Error to award father ultimate decision-making authority over children's extracurricular activities where father did not request such relief -- Trial court erred in failing to attach copy of parenting plan to final judgment. ANDREA M. PICARD, Appellant, v. JONATHAN R. PICARD, Appellee. 2nd District.

 

 Contracts -- Employment -- Noncompete agreement -- Injunctions -- Temporary -- Legitimate business interest -- Extraordinary or specialized training -- Trial court erred by entering preliminary injunction enforcing a non-compete agreement because plaintiff, a terrazzo restoration company, did not prove that an injunction enforcing the restrictive covenants contained in the agreement was necessary to protect a legitimate business interest -- Evidence did not support finding that plaintiff had provided defendant with specialized or extraordinary training where the evidence, even when construed in a light most favorable to plaintiff, established that defendant received on-the-job training that was “usual, regular, common or customary in the industry”. RUSSEL VESSELS, JR AND COAST TO COAST TERRAZZO, LLC, Appellants, v. DR. TERRAZZO OF FLORIDA, LLC D/B/A DR. TERRAZZO, Appellee. 5th District.



Contracts -- Notes -- Limitation of actions -- Equitable estoppel -- Action seeking repayment of promissory note from borrower's estate -- Trial court erred in entering summary judgment in favor of estate based on finding that statute of limitations had expired -- Plaintiff's summary judgment evidence was sufficient to support plaintiff's argument that equitable estoppel precluded estate from asserting statute of limitations as a defense to suit where plaintiff's affidavit in opposition asserted that plaintiff did not sue earlier because borrower had repeatedly asked plaintiff not to sue and assured plaintiff that he would be paid as recently as within a year of borrower's death. ANTHONY J. IEMMA, Appellant, v. MARGARET HEICHBERGER, as Personal Representative of the ESTATE OF JOSEPH P. D'ANGELO, and INGRID PALMER, Appellees. 4th District.


Dissolution of marriage -- Equitable distribution -- Marital/nonmarital assets -- Retirement benefits -- Settlement agreement -- Settlement agreement requiring the parties to equally divide the portion of former husband's retirement plan acquired from the time of the marriage to the filing of the dissolution of marriage petition, “plus any gains or losses on that amount” -- In calculating amount of retirement plan the parties were entitled to, the trial court erred by first subtracting former husband's premarital interest from the value of the plan at the time dissolution of marriage litigation commenced and then dividing the remaining balance equally -- Trial court's calculation resulted in former wife receiving passive appreciation of former husband's premarital interest in the retirement plan -- Contractual term “plus any gains or losses on that amount” does not apply to any passive appreciation in former husband's nonmarital portion of the retirement plan -- Remanded for the entry of a new qualified domestic relations order that subtracts former husband's premarital balance, plus that amount constituting passive appreciation on this premarital balance, from the final value of the plan, and then equally divides the remaining net amount between the parties. MATTHEW FRANK BALAZIC, Appellant, v. JULIE ANN BALAZIC, Appellee. 5th District.

 

Dissolution of marriage -- Alimony -- Need and ability to pay -- Retroactive alimony -- Equitable distribution -- Valuation of assets -- Businesses -- Attorney's fees -- Trial court failed to make adequate findings supporting award of permanent periodic alimony where final judgment did not make clear how trial court resolved conflicting evidence concerning former wife' s monthly living expenses or how trial court determined that former husband could pay the amount awarded -- Furthermore, trial court was required to find that no other form of alimony was appropriate -- Trial court erred in its valuation of former husband's business where it only accounted for business assets without considering business liabilities -- Award of attorney's fees is reversed where order does not make specific findings relating to hourly rate, the number of hours reasonably expended, and any appropriate reduction or enhancement factors -- Error to award retroactive alimony. TOMMY WAYNE GUIMBELLOT, Appellant, v. PATRICIA LYNN GUIMBELLOT, Appellee. 1st District.

 

Dissolution of marriage -- Equitable distribution -- Retirement benefits -- Settlement agreement -- Enforcement -- Wife's request for lump sum payment to effectuate award of wife's portion of husband's retirement and survivor benefits was appropriate where husband had purposefully and deceptively taken the entire benefit for himself and his current wife and flouted multiple trial court orders, his own attorney's instructions, and terms of parties' marital settlement agreement -- Testimony of wife's expert as to present value of benefit was not rendered speculative by expert's use of social security life expectancy calculator. HENRY SAKOW, Appellant/Cross-Appellee, v. LINDA BLAYLOCK f/k/a Linda Sakow, Appellee/Cross-Appellant. 1st District.


Dissolution of marriage -- Psychological evaluation -- Trial court did not depart from essential requirements of law by requiring former husband to submit to psychological evaluation after determining, following evidentiary hearing, that husband's mental health was at issue and mental health evaluation was appropriate -- Trial court erred in failing to specify time, place, manner, conditions, and scope of evaluation and failing to establish person or persons by whom the interview is to be made -- Remand to permit trial court to enter order that complies with rule 12.360(a)(1)(B). DORIAN CHILDS, Petitioner, v. LETICIA CRUZ-CHILDS, Respondent. 2nd District.

 

Torts -- Contracts -- Limited liability companies -- Officers and directors -- Fraud -- Individual liability -- Active participation theory -- Claim that president of LLC made fraudulent representations that LLC held title to property that was offered to plaintiff investors as collateral in exchange for plaintiffs' loan to LLC despite knowledge that LLC did not have title -- Trial court erred in entering summary judgment in favor of president based on determination that president could not be held individually liable -- Independent tort doctrine did not prevent president from being held personally liable -- Doctrine only applies to the parties to a contract, and it is undisputed that president was only a signatory for LLC and not a party to the loan and security agreement -- President was not entitled to summary judgment based on trial court's conclusion that president had not made any false statements of material fact where agreement and borrower's certificate, both signed by president on behalf of LLC, made false statements of existing fact regarding LLC's ownership of subject property -- Under active participation theory, president may be held individually liable for the fraud evidenced by agreement and certificate even though he signed as a corporate officer of LLC -- Trial court erred in finding that contract absolved president from liability where provisions relied upon were inapplicable, and contract expressly stated that officers could be liable for fraud or intentional misconduct. COSTA INVESTORS, LLC, Appellant, v. LIBERTY GRANDE, LLC and MOSES BENSUSAN, Appellees. 4th District.

 

Wrongful death -- Contracts -- Release -- Exculpatory clause -- Punitive damages -- Claims of negligence and breach of fiduciary duty brought against university by estate of football player who died of cardiac event after participating in football practice were not barred by exculpatory clauses in releases signed by decedent in order to play football for university -- Exculpatory clause relied upon by university was unenforceable where it failed to expressly inform player that he was contracting away his right to sue university for its own negligence, included language that could reasonably lead one to believe that university would be supervising and training properly so that player was only being asked to sign exculpatory clause to cover injuries inherent in sport, and used language suggesting that terms of release were for player's benefit -- Amendment of complaint -- Trial court erred in granting motion to amend complaint to add claim for punitive damages where record evidence fell short of demonstrating gross negligence. THE ESTATE OF NICHOLAS ADAM BLAKELY, BY AND THROUGH MICHELLE WILSON, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, Appellant, v. STETSON UNIVERSITY, INC., Appellee. 5th District.

Monday, December 2, 2019

Fiduciary duties, contempt, marital liabilities, and coffee-garlic marinated bison with grilled fennel and rosemary


Contracts -- Real property -- Escrow agent -- Fiduciary duty -- Action against defendant escrow agent alleging that defendant breached fiduciary duty owed to plaintiff by distributing escrow funds to third-party developer for purposes not authorized in purchase agreement between developer and plaintiff, but which were authorized in escrow agreement between developer and defendant -- No error in granting summary judgment in favor of defendant -- There was no genuine issue of material fact about whether plaintiff's counsel negotiated, or had authority to negotiate, the escrow agreement -- Counsel's authority to negotiate terms of escrow agreement was immaterial to plaintiff's claims because defendant owed no duty to plaintiff who was not a party to the escrow agreement -- No genuine issue of material fact existed as to whether defendant had authority to disburse the escrow funds -- Fact that escrow agreement had not been fully executed when funds were transferred did not alter defendant's obligations as escrow agent because defendant's execution of the escrow agreement was not a condition precedent to implementing the terms of the agreement. CARTER DEVELOPMENT OF MASSACHUSETTS, LLC, Appellant, v. G. ALAN HOWARD and MILAM HOWARD NICANDRI DEES & GILLAM, P.A., Appellees. 1st District.


Dissolution of marriage -- Contempt -- Trial court erred by holding former husband in contempt for failure to pay alimony and child support pursuant to a marital settlement agreement entered into by parties in a dissolution action five years earlier which had been dismissed without the court having approved or adopted the agreement -- Trial court's conclusion that doctrine of laches has been abolished in Florida is legally incorrect -- Terms of settlement agreement may not be enforced nunc pro tunc five years later via contempt, as opposed to enforcement in an ordinary civil money judgment for the months of non-compliance prior to filing of current dissolution action. VINCENT J. THILLOY, Appellant, v. ANN M. CICCONE-CAPRI, Appellee. 3rd District.


Dissolution of marriage -- Equitable distribution -- Marital liabilities -- Loans -- Trial court erred in ruling that former wife had no obligations as to a loan given to the parties by former husband's mother during the marriage -- Trial court must treat the debt as a marital liability and order distribution of it accordingly where trial court made no finding of misconduct, failed to consider the factors listed in section 61.075(1), and failed to articulate a sufficient justification to allocate the loan solely to former husband -- On remand, trial court need not make any determinations as to the true value of the promissory note securing the loan where issue was not previously put before the trial court. DENNIS K. BURNS, Former Husband, Appellant, v. CYNTHIA S. COLE, Former Wife, Appellee. 1st District.


Dissolution of marriage -- Judgment -- Trial court, under facts of case, did not abuse discretion in adopting wife's proposed final judgment where both parties were represented by counsel, husband was given a copy of wife's proposed final judgment, trial court signed wife's proposed final judgment two-and-a-half months after receiving competing orders, husband raised no objections to proposed judgment, and trial court's hand-written notations on judgment before signing it implicate court's independent evaluation of submitted findings -- Record supports conclusion that trial court exercised independent decision-making where court actively participated in final hearing -- Moreover, husband, who failed to raise an objection to wife's proposed final judgment on rehearing, cannot for first time on appeal raise an objection to proposed final judgment based upon court's “virtually verbatim” adoption of proposed judgment -- Child custody -- Trial court abused discretion in awarding sole parental responsibility to wife where wife did not request sole parental responsibility and there is no “logical or reasonable justification” for award that would support conclusion that shared parental responsibility was detrimental to minor children -- On remand, trial court is instructed to amend final judgment to award shared parental responsibility, and to remove all findings and inflammatory remarks related to issue of parental responsibility -- Domestic violence injunction -- To extent final judgment grants wife what amounts to a de facto domestic violence injunction against husband, trial court acted without proper statutory authority where record is devoid of any facts showing wife had standing to file petition for domestic violence or showing husband was provided notice and hearing before entry of injunction -- Life insurance -- Trial court erred in requiring husband, who is receiving child support, to name wife as beneficiary to his existing life insurance, absent appropriate circumstances requiring him to maintain such policy -- Husband's advanced age of seventy with two minor children does not qualify as a special or appropriate circumstance. BENJAMIN A. MUSGRAVE, Appellant, v. LYNN M. MUSGRAVE, Appellee. 2nd District.


Dissolution of marriage -- Property settlement agreement -- Enforcement -- Jurisdiction -- Scope of family court's continuing jurisdiction -- Family court judge erred in awarding money damages for husband's breach of parties' settlement agreement where the agreement did not specify the damages sought by former wife and awarded by the court -- Award of damages for husband's delayed delivery of stock and failure to deliver accurate tax information, together with injunction intended to secure the payment of those damages, reversed. TODD KOZEL, Appellant, v. ASHLEY D. KOZEL, Appellee. 2nd District.


The Law Lady.  For more info about us, click here.  To be added to our email circulation with MUCH, MUCH more law, click here and specify whether you wish to be added to our CRIMINAL, CIVIL, or  FEDERAL Recent Decisions of Interest.

Monday, February 1, 2016

Wrongful death, new trials, appellee sanctions, and Bison with Kale, Rosemary, and Purple potatoes with Lemon Thyme



Appeals -- Sanctions -- Maintenance of indefensible position in trial court and on appeal -- Rare circumstance in which appellee may be sanctioned -- Appellee complying with none of court deadlines -- Appellee directed to show cause why appellant's attorney's fees should not be assessed against appellee
HSBC Bank USA, N.A., Appellant, vs. BISCAYNE POINT CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, Appellee. 3rd District.

Child custody -- Timesharing -- Error to modify timesharing by restricting contact to one time per week in a supervised setting without identifying what steps parent must take in order to reestablish unsupervised timesharing
IEHUDA TZYNDER, Appellant, vs. KEREN EDELSBURG, Appellee. 3rd District.

Civil procedure -- Summary judgment -- Mortgage foreclosure -- Standing -- Substituted plaintiff -- Trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of new plaintiff, to whom mortgage had been assigned, substituted for predecessor plaintiff on same day as hearing on motion for summary judgment, because the assignment from the predecessor plaintiff, which was not in the evidentiary record, leaves standing as an issue of material fact not conclusively established by the pleadings or other summary judgment evidence -- An order of substitution does not create standing -- No merit to successor plaintiff's argument that, because the assignment was a recorded document, the trial court could properly take judicial note of it -- Even if judicially noticed, plaintiff cannot rely on it for standing because it was not served at least 20 days before the hearing on summary judgment
GREGORY SANDEFUR, Appellant, v. RVS CAPITAL, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, RIO VISTA SALOON, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, and DAVID ZWICK, Appellees. 4th District.

Contracts -- Construction -- Arbitration -- Determination of arbitrability of breach of contract claim -- By incorporating into contract the Construction Industry Rules of the American Arbitration Association, which make the issue of arbitrability subject to arbitration, parties sufficiently evidenced intent to have arbitrators, not a court, hear and decide the issue of arbitrability
GLASSWALL, LLC, Appellant, vs. MONADNOCK CONSTRUCTION, INC., et al., Appellees. 3rd District.

Contracts -- Fraud in the inducement -- Economic loss rule -- Claim that defendant fraudulently induced plaintiff to join auto-racing team by misrepresenting that defendant was fully funded and did not need plaintiff's money in order to run the team -- Because defendant's fraudulent representations were of a present fact, the fraudulent misrepresentation claim did not merge with plaintiff's breach of contract claim, and was not barred by economic loss rule -- Trial court erred in granting defendant's motion for judgment notwithstanding verdict for plaintiff on fraudulent inducement claim -- Attorneys -- Trial court did not abuse discretion by denying out-of-state attorney's motion to appear pro hac vice on the basis that granting of motion would adversely impact the administration of justice and disrupt the proceedings
PREWITT ENTERPRISES, LLC, Appellant, v. TOMMY CONSTANTINE RACING, LLC, a foreign limited liability company, and TOMMY CONSTANTINE, a/k/a THOMAS CONSTANTINE, individually, Appellees. 4th District.

Costs -- Section 57.105 does not provide mechanism for recovering costs
GRAND RESERVE AT TAMPA CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC., and BUSINESS LAW GROUP, P.A., Appellants, v. HSBC BANK USA, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, AS TRUSTEE FOR NOMURA ASSET ACCEPTANCE CORPORATION MORTGAGE PASS-THROUGH CERTIFICATES, SERIES 2006-AF1, Appellee. 2nd District.

Creditors' rights -- Execution of consent judgment -- Motion to stay writ of execution and vacate levy on debtors' personal residence on ground that residence was debtors' homestead -- Trial court denied debtors due process when it refused to hear debtors' homestead exemption objection -- Objection was raised in emergency motion to stay and was therefore before the trial court at the time of hearing; counsel for debtors told court that he had argument pertaining to emergency motion to stay that did not pertain to issues in the motion to vacate consent judgment, but trial court erroneously determined that motion to stay did not contain any argument separate from arguments raised in motion to vacate consent judgment; and counsel clearly informed court in a timely motion for rehearing that separate homestead objection remained unresolved -- Remand for further proceedings
ROBERT MILLARD HAYES and LINDA WEBSTER HAYES, husband and wife, Appellants, v. NORMAN HARRIS SERVICES, INC.; GORDON CUTHBERTSON; and ENVIROGREEN LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE, INC., a Florida corporation, Appellees. 2nd District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Equitable distribution -- Trial court exceeded scope of appellate mandate by revaluing assets and liabilities, including revisiting issue of value of former husband's dental practice, and by reducing duration of alimony award -- Trial court did not exceed scope of remand by considering evidence regarding former husband's current income, which was relevant to amount of alimony and issue of whether husband could be compelled to pay for minor child's private school tuition -- Remand with instructions to split net proceeds, if any, from sale of marital home and redistribute remaining assets and liabilities in original equitable distribution schedule without revaluing them; and to reinstate ten-year duration of alimony from date of original final judgment -- Appellate court declines to revisit prior ruling that trial court erred in failing to partition marital home where arguments former wife raised on this issue could have been advanced in motion for rehearing in earlier appeal -- Imputed income -- Competent substantial evidence supported amount of income imputed to former wife -- Attorney's fees to be reconsidered on remand in light of appellate court's reversal of trial court's decision to revalue assets -- Alimony credit -- Appeal from award of alimony credit to husband is premature where trial court determined entitlement but did not determine amount of credit -- Private school tuition -- Competent substantial evidence supported trial court's finding that former husband did not have ability to pay child's private school expenses
MARIANNE K. BRENNAN, Appellant, v. DANIEL JOSEPH BRENNAN, Appellee. 4th District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Marital home -- Error to include in final judgment language specifying that former wife must refinance or sell marital home within 18 months without addressing each party's financial responsibilities prior to sale of home and consequences should former wife fail to sell or refinance home within allotted time frame -- With respect to provision assigning value to home and specifying that each party was to receive half of that assigned value in the event that the home was sold, although actual sale price might vary from the assigned value, former husband is entitled to equal share of the actual refinancing value or sale price of home -- Equitable distribution -- Various errors in calculation of equitable distribution in final judgment to be corrected
KEITH A. JONES, Appellant, v. LESLIE D. JONES, Appellee. 5th District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Settlement agreement -- Enforcement -- Estates -- Motion to enforce marital settlement agreement insofar as it addressed disposition of three parcels in the Cayman Islands owned by husband and wife as joint tenancy with rights of survivorship, filed by personal representative of former husband, who died four years after divorce -- Trial court erred in ordering former wife to whom properties passed upon death of former husband either to sell properties or to purchase former husband's interest in them -- Under both unambiguous provisions of former husband's will, which was executed at time husband instituted dissolution proceedings, and Cayman Islands law, disputed parcels became former wife's sole property when former husband died -- Although marital settlement agreement stated that parties would try to sell Cayman Island properties “within a reasonable time” and provided that either party could buy out the other party's interest at any time, it did not require that parties would be forced to sell property immediately if one did not buy out the other -- Error to grant estate's motion to enforce final judgment and marital settlement agreement against former wife -- Order prohibiting former wife from dissipating, encumbering, transferring, or selling these properties to be vacated on remand
DIANE MARIE EBANKS, Appellant, v. CURTIS EBANKS, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Arthur Ebanks, Appellee. 2nd District.



Insurance -- Discovery -- Trial court departed from essential requirements of law in ordering insurer to produce portions of its adjusters' claims files to medical provider in first-party non-bad-faith cases
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY, Petitioner, vs. PREMIER DIAGNOSTIC CENTERS, LLC, (A/A/O SHERRY DUJON, DOLORES LANCASTER, MARIA LOPEZ), Respondent. 3rd District.

Insurance -- Uninsured motorist -- Argument -- Insurer entitled to new trial based on cumulative effect of statements by plaintiff's counsel pointing out that plaintiff had done the right thing all along and that insurer had refused to pay the debt it owed to plaintiff, counsel's use of PowerPoint slide visible to jury that emphasized the insurer's responsibility, and an instruction by the trial court which also focused on insurer's liability rather than on the issue of actual damages attributable to the accident
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellant, v. MICHAEL D. GOLD and GINA GOLD, individually and as husband and wife, Appellees. 4th District.

Judges -- Disqualification -- Motion to disqualify judge was legally sufficient to extent it relied upon specific campaign-related issues, including fact that at least one of opposing party's counsel was playing significant role in judge's current, ongoing reelection campaign -- Prohibition granted
ERIC RIVERA, Petitioner, v. JOSHUA BOSQUE, Respondent. 5th District.

Jurisdiction -- Non-residents -- Contracts -- Failure to pay on contract requiring payment in Florida is sufficient to satisfy Florida's long-arm statute conferring jurisdiction over breach of contract actions -- Minimum contacts -- Where neither amended complaint nor testimony at hearing on jurisdiction showed that any act beyond repayment of promissory note was required to be performed in Florida, defendant did not have sufficient minimum contacts with state to support assertion of personal jurisdiction -- Remand with directions to dismiss without prejudice to refiling complaint in appropriate forum
CORNERSTONE INVESTMENT FUNDING, LLC, Appellant, v. PAINTED POST GROUP, INC., Appellee. 4th District.

Municipal corporations -- Trial court erred in dismissing complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief seeking to void city's alleged ultra vires act of confirming parking credits that served to reduce a building's parking space obligation -- It was error to dismiss complaint on ground that Design Review Board determined that building qualified for an allowance of parking space credits, that city granted a parking variance, and that plaintiff's action is procedurally barred because plaintiff failed to timely challenge City Planning Department's administrative determination contained in Design Review Board resolution -- Findings made by trial court in granting motion to dismiss complaint are not supported by allegations of complaint -- Dismissal cannot be affirmed on basis of res judicata or collateral estoppel, as there has not been a prior determination on the merits -- There is no merit to claim that separation of powers bars complaint because it attempts to challenge an executive act of city -- Plaintiff is not requesting that city perform a discretionary act, but, rather, alleged that city engaged in an ultra vires act
NEAPOLITAN ENTERPRISES, LLC, Appellant, v. THE CITY OF NAPLES, OLDE NAPLES BUILDING LLC, and BROAD AVENUE LLC, Appellees. 2nd District.

Torts -- Assignment of claims -- Action by plaintiff against his residential tenant, alleging that tenant was negligent in connection with a fire that damaged plaintiff's property -- Trial court did not err in entering summary judgment for defendant on basis that plaintiff, in mortgage, had assigned rights to recover for property damage to mortgagee
JORGE ARTILES, Appellant, vs. YURISBEL PINO, et al., Appellees. 3rd District.

Torts -- Cruise ships -- Jurisdiction -- Forum non conveniens -- Two class action suits against cruise line by U.S. and non-U.S. passengers on Italian-flagged cruise ship which ran aground in Italy -- Trial court did not err in dismissing one action for forum non conveniens upon finding that Italy is an available and adequate forum, that private interest and public interest factors favor trial in Italy, and that plaintiffs can reinstate their suit in Italy without undue inconvenience or prejudice -- In failing to dismiss U.S. plaintiffs in other action court did not conduct a proper private interest analysis when it failed to consider the necessary evidence required to prove and disprove each element of plaintiffs' cause of action
DENISE ABEID-SABA, et al., Appellants/Appellees/Cross-Appellees, vs. CARNIVAL CORP., CARNIVAL PLC, COSTA CROCIERE, S.p.A., COSTA CRUISE LINES, INC., and JOSEPH FARCUS ARCHITECT, P.A., Appellees/Appellants/Cross-Appellants. 3rd District.

Torts -- Evidence -- Action against automobile dealer that sold truck with lift kit installed to initial purchaser and automobile dealer who subsequently sold truck to plaintiff, who was injured when truck's steering and suspension failed, resulting in truck flipping over -- Trial court did not err in striking affidavit of plaintiff's expert witness, filed after defendants had filed motion for summary judgment, which expressed opinion that dealer who sold truck to plaintiff failed to take action which could have prevented accident where witness's prior deposition testimony stated that he had no opinion regarding the conduct of defendants -- Witness's affidavit was inconsistent with his earlier deposition testimony without any explanation for the inconsistency -- Trial court did not abuse discretion by applying rule that a litigant, when confronted with an adverse motion for summary judgment, may not contradict or disavow prior sworn testimony with contradictory sworn affidavit testimony -- Trial court did not err in entering summary judgment for defendants where there was no evidence that truck was defective when sold by initial seller and no evidence that second seller of truck had a duty to inspect the truck for latent defects
SHAUN LESNIK, Appellant, v. DUVAL FORD, LLC, a Florida corporation and BURKINS CHEVROLET, INC., a Florida corporation, Appellees. 1st District.

Wrongful death -- Medical malpractice -- New trial -- Plaintiff suffered prejudice where, shortly before trial, defendant amended Fabre defense to include other physicians as non-party defendants and then withdrew the Fabre defense on the last day of trial -- Events created situation in which plaintiff presented case premised on fact that jury would apportion fault between defendant and Fabre defendants, only to have jury to decide case on an all-or-nothing basis -- Trial court abused discretion in denying plaintiff's motion for new trial
JEFFREY M. EDWARDS, as Personal Representative of the Estate of MARY EDWARDS, deceased, for and on behalf of lawful survivors/claimants; JEFFREY M. EDWARDS, surviving spouse; JEFFREY M. EDWARDS, JR., surviving minor child; CARL A. EDWARDS, surviving minor child; and MATTHEW T. EDWARDS, surviving minor child, Appellants, v. JEFFREY ROSEN, M.D.; FLORIDA HEART ASSOCIATES, P.L.; SHAHEEN FARUQUE, M.D.; INPATIENT CONSULTANTS OF FLORIDA, INC.; IMTIAZ AHMAD, M.D.; ALLERGY, SLEEP AND LUNG CARE, P.A.; and LEE MEMORIAL HEALTH SYSTEM, Appellees. 2nd District.



The Law Lady.  For more info about us, click here.  To be added to our email circulation with MUCH, MUCH more law, click here and specify whether you wish to be added to our CRIMINAL, CIVIL, or  FEDERAL Recent Decisions of Interest.