Showing posts with label torts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label torts. Show all posts

Friday, January 13, 2023

Arbitration, timesharing modifications, void judgments, and stoneground grits with fennel, roasted peppers, and spicy italian sausage

Arbitration -- Torts -- Residential communities -- Arbitration clause in home purchase and sale agreement and identical clause in deed encompassed purchaser/property owner's claim against developer for personal injuries sustained while riding his bicycle on roadway within residential community where clauses expressly and unambiguously included claims relating to personal injury or property damages “in the community” within the disputes to be submitted to arbitration. LENNAR HOMES, LLC, Appellant, v. MATTHEW WILKINSKY, Appellee. 4th District.

Attorney's fees -- Prevailing party -- Voluntary dismissal -- Where all counts in complaint involved the same facts and the same parties, trial court's order dismissing one of multiple counts was not a final order and did not dispose of the action for either party -- Plaintiff's subsequent notice of voluntary dismissal disposed of the action as to both parties and triggered 30-day time frame for filing motion for attorney's fees -- Trial court erred in reversing its initial award of fees to defendant after concluding that motion should have been filed within 30 days of court's non-final dismissal order. SARA WARD, Appellant, v. RIVKA LIEBER, as Personal Representative of the ESTATE OF LILLIAN K. WASSERMAN, Appellee. 4th District.

 Child custody -- Time-sharing -- Modification -- Relocation with child -- Mother was not required to seek leave of court or to consult with father before relocating with children to another county where at time of move paternity had not been established -- Trial court reversibly erred by considering statutes which did not apply to mother's move when entering custody and time-sharing orders following father's filing of petition to determine paternity. DEARLYN LOJARES, Appellant, v. ALFONSO SILVA, Appellee. 1st District.

Civil procedure -- Default -- Vacation -- A trial court's failure to make oral or written findings in support of an order vacating a default judgment supports reversal only where the record does not contain any facts to support that decision -- Neither Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.540(b), Florida Supreme Court, nor Fourth District Court of Appeal has imposed any requirement that a trial court must make oral or written findings to support an order vacating a default judgment -- On the merits, the circuit court had a factual basis to grant escrow agent's amended motion to vacate both the clerk's default and the circuit court's default judgment against the escrow agent -- Defenses of due diligence, excusable neglect, and meritorious defense were, at least facially, meritorious. FI CAPITAL INVESTMENT 19, LLC, Appellant, v. SOUTH FLORIDA TITLE ASSOCIATES, LLC, et al., Appellees. 4th District.

Civil procedure -- Default -- Void judgment -- Damages -- Liquidated/unliquidated damages -- Action seeking collection on unpaid promissory note -- Default final judgment was void where judgment reflected unliquidated damages and was entered without a hearing -- The otherwise liquidated amount under original promissory note was rendered unliquidated where there was a separate default final judgment entered against a co-promisor and a satisfaction of judgment as to co-promisor without any indication of the amount paid. ANTHONY LIND MAIURI, Appellant, v. FIRST AMERICAN TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellee. 3rd District.

Civil procedure -- Dismissal -- Failure to comply with court order -- Error to dismiss lawsuit with prejudice where plaintiff was not given notice or opportunity to be heard and order was not accompanied by finding of deliberate and contumacious disregard for trial court's authority, bad faith, gross indifference, or conduct evincing deliberate callousness. DON SMITH, Appellant, v. LISA MELTZER, etc., Appellee. 3rd District.

Contracts -- Breach of contract -- Corporations -- Successor liability -- Alter ego -- No error in allowing plaintiff to file supplemental complaint to implead defendant corporation as alter ego and successor entity of separate corporation against which plaintiff had obtained money judgment -- Evidence supported three of the four exceptions to corporate law rule that the liability of a predecessor corporation is not imposed upon successor companies. J&R UNITED INDUSTRIES, INC., etc., Appellant, v. STEPHEN E. MIRON, etc., Appellee. 3rd District.

Contracts -- Dismissal -- Fraud on court -- No abuse of discretion in granting defendant's motion to strike complaint for fraud on court alleging that plaintiff submitted a fabricated contract and that plaintiff's corporate representative falsely testified at deposition that fabricated contract was true and correct copy -- Legibility of the sued-upon contract was material to plaintiff's claim, and plaintiff failed to file a response to the motion or present any evidence in opposition. ORACLE ELEVATOR COMPANY, etc., Appellant, v. 8660 BUILDING, LLC, etc., Appellee. 3rd District.

Contracts -- Employment -- Arbitration -- No error in denying motion to compel arbitration where substantial competent evidence in record supports trial court's finding that plaintiff did not electronically sign the arbitration agreement. GR OPCO, LLC, etc., Appellant, v. ANA PAOLA MURILLO, Appellee. 3rd District.

Creditors' rights -- Proceedings supplementary -- Fraudulent transfers -- Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act -- Subsequent transferees -- Final summary judgment declaring transfer of condominium unit void as a fraudulent transfer was supported by evidence establishing undisputed existence of seven badges of fraud -- Discussion of badges of fraud in section 726.105(2) in context of case at issue involving series of transfers and shifting corporate entities -- Good faith -- Trial court properly rejected good faith defense asserted by corporate transferee that paid nothing for condominium unit -- Civil procedure -- Summary judgment -- Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying motion for rehearing in light of new affidavits asserting additional facts. MANE FL CORP., Appellant, v. CALE BECKMAN and MALGORZATA BECKMAN, Appellees. 4th District.

Declaratory judgments -- Wrongful death -- School shooting -- Action against firearm manufacturer and seller of firearm used by gunman -- Trial court did not err in dismissing complaint for declaratory relief after concluding that plaintiffs' request for declaration that section 790.331 prohibits only suits by state actors against firearms manufacturers, not those brought by private citizens, was, in fact, an impermissible attempt to solicit advisory opinion that would help them decide whether they should file a suit. FREDRICK GUTTENBERG and JENNIFER GUTTENBERG, as Co-Personal Representatives of the ESTATE OF JAIME T. GUTTENBERG, Appellants, v. SMITH & WESSON CORP., n/k/a SMITH & WESSON SALES COMPANY, INC., and SUNRISE TACTICAL SUPPLY, LLC, Appellees. 4th District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Child support -- Modification -- Marital settlement agreement -- Trial court erred in granting mother's exceptions to general magistrate's report and recommendation concerning father's child support obligations based on its determination that trial court lacked inherent or statutory authority to modify child support -- Trial court maintained authority to modify father's child support obligations despite language in parties' marital settlement agreement setting a minimum amount of support that the father must pay -- Because the general magistrate's findings regarding the parties' financial status, change in circumstances, and children's best interests were supported by competent substantial evidence, the trial court should have accepted them. JAMES W. FUNDERBURK, Appellant, v. MARCI L. RICENBAW f/k/a MARCI L. FUNDERBURK, Appellee. 2nd District.

 

Judges -- Disqualification -- Taking allegations that trial court made improper comments at calendar call as true, disqualification of judge is warranted and petition for writ of prohibition is granted. ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ, et al., Petitioners, v. ROHAN HALSALL, Respondent. 3rd District.

Limited liability companies -- Shareholders -- Direct/derivative actions -- Contracts -- Torts -- Jury trial -- Entitlement -- Action alleging both direct and derivative legal and equitable claims against defendant shareholder and separate entity owned by defendant shareholder -- Breach of contract claim sufficiently alleged direct harm and special injury where plaintiff claimed that defendant's breach of LLC's operating agreement by misappropriating loan proceeds diluted plaintiff's ownership percentage in the LLC -- Because plaintiff sufficiently alleged direct harm and special injury, breach of contract claim was a direct legal claim for which a right to jury trial existed -- Trial court erred by trying equitable, derivative claims against defendant shareholder's other business separately in a non-jury trial while breach of contract claim was still pending -- Contract claim and the derivative equitable claims were intertwined because they all revolved around underlying factual issues regarding defendant's purported mismanagement of LLC and alleged misappropriation of loan proceeds -- Because contract claim was factually intertwined with equitable claims, a jury was required to resolve the common factual issues -- Proper procedure would have been for trial court to first proceed with jury trial and then apply jury's factual findings to determine whether plaintiff established entitlement to relief on his equitable claims -- Trial court erred in relying on business judgment rule to decide derivative claim against separate entity alleging that entity aided and abetted defendant shareholder's breach of fiduciary duty where defendant shareholder was not a disinterested party to any of the transactions at issue -- Key inquiry is whether defendant shareholder's self-interested transactions were valid under law governing conflict-of-interest transactions for limited liability companies. ALDO DISORBO, Appellant, v. AMERICAN VAN LINES, INC., Appellee. 4th District.

Mortgage foreclosure -- Sale -- Objection -- Timeliness -- No error in denying borrower's objection to sale of foreclosed property alleging that clerk's advertisement was defective where objection was raised more than ten days after sale -- While borrower was granted a stay of the sale, that stay was entered to allow borrower to redeem and purchase the property, not to raise further objections. CEDRIC McINTYRE, etc., Appellant, v. CIT BANK, N.A., Appellee. 3rd District.

Real property -- Easements -- Injunctions -- Trial court erred in determining that proposed development of servient estate was precluded by easement and agreed permanent injunction enforcing the easement, which enjoined servient estate from “interfering with” dominant estate's right to ingress and egress, based on finding that increased traffic resulting from development of servient estate would “interfere” with dominant estate's easement rights -- While broad dictionary term of “interfering” could, in isolation, support dominant estate's position that interference means delaying or slowing down ingress and egress, such a definition is not supported by the easement or by the entire text of the agreed permanent injunction itself -- In context, best interpretation of “interfering” is not something that simply hinders, but rather something that obstructs access. 7 AT BLUE LAGOON (1), LLC, et al., Appellants, v. BLUE LAGOON CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC., Appellee. 3rd District.

Torts -- Jurors -- Peremptory challenge -- Race-neutral explanation -- Genuineness -- No abuse of discretion in determining that plaintiff's proffered reason for exercising peremptory challenge as to Hispanic female juror was not genuine. AIRAM BULTE, Appellant, v. DOLLAR TREE STORES, INC., etc., Appellee. 3rd District.

Wrongful death -- Product liability -- Tobacco -- Punitive damages -- Excessive award -- Remittitur -- Trial court abused its discretion in denying remittitur of punitive damages that exceeded net compensatory damages award by a ratio of 106.7 to 1 -- While it was not unreasonable to conclude that facts and circumstances of case under review supported a departure from the 3:1 statutory cap, a trial court in a wrongful death action abuses its discretion by denying remittitur of a punitive damages award that does not bear a reasonable relation to the amount of damages proved and the injury suffered by the statutory beneficiaries -- Court rejects argument that the injury suffered in a wrongful death action is decedent's death because Wrongful Death Act provides that the injury suffered in such an action is to the decedent's statutory beneficiaries, not the decedent -- Injury suffered by the survivors in case under review is the injury reflected in the compensatory damages award that the jury found to represent the total amount of the damages that decedent's survivors sustained for the loss of parental companionship, instruction, and guidance, and from their mental pain and suffering as a result of decedent's illness and death -- Although higher dollar awards of punitive damages have been approved in other tobacco cases, statutory analysis of whether a punitive damages award bears a reasonable relation to the amount of damages proven and the injury suffered is necessarily case-specific. BRINDA COATES, etc., Petitioner, v. R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY, Respondent. Supreme Court of Florida.

Wrongful death -- Suicide -- Arbitration -- Arbitrable issues -- Trial court erred in denying motion to dismiss or to compel arbitration in action against private school and individual defendant brought by parent of student who committed suicide following school's request that he withdraw from school for selling vape pen to another student, alleging school violated its policies and procedures and common law duty to assess and provide suicide prevention and crisis support to a disciplined student -- Arbitration clauses in enrollment contract and student handbook were sufficiently narrow in scope -- Although sounding entirely in tort and not specifically including breach of contract claim, claims alleged in complaint have direct relationship to the enrollment contract and handbook's terms and provisions, and complaint expressly relies on enrollment contract and handbook to establish school's duty to student. CALVARY CHAPEL CHURCH, INC. d/b/a CALVARY CHRISTIAN ACADEMY, CALVARY CHAPEL OF FT. LAUDERDALE, INC., and JOSEPH WILSON, Appellants, v. COLLEEN HAPP, as Personal Representative of the ESTATE OF COLIN CHARLES HAPP, Appellee. 4th District.

 

The Law Lady.  For more info about us, click here.  To be added to our email circulation with MUCH, MUCH more law, click here and specify whether you wish to be added to our CRIMINAL, CIVIL, or  FEDERAL Recent Decisions of Interest.

 

Monday, May 10, 2021

Wrongful death, arbitration, juror challenges, dissolution of marriage, and grilled salmon with fresh ginger and wasabi

Appeals -- Second-tier certiorari review of circuit court appellate division order reversing hearing officer's determination that respondent was in violation of County Code -- Circuit court applied correct law in determining whether hearing officer's findings were supported by competent substantial evidence and in finding that hearing officer had denied respondent due process -- Circuit court improperly remanded case with instructions to dismiss citation -- Available remedy to circuit court in granting writ of certiorari was limited to quashing hearing officer's order, and nothing more. MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, Petitioner, v. SNAPP INDUSTRIES, INC., Respondent. 3rd District.

Civil procedure -- Amendment of answer -- Trial court abused discretion in denying defendant's ore tenus motion, made at summary judgment hearing, to amend answer to assert affirmative defense -- Defendant had not abused privilege to amend, plaintiff would not be prejudiced by amendment, and amendment would not be futile. MISHPAJA SHAJINE, INC., et al., Appellants, v. GRANADA INSURANCE COMPANY, et al., Appellees. 3rd District.

Civil procedure -- Discovery -- Business records -- Examination -- Transport of documents -- Appeals -- Certiorari -- Trial court departed from essential requirements of the law by requiring party to transport original corporate documents from California to opposing counsel in Florida where opposing party did not identify any reason to do so. LE-1, a Florida Limited Liability Company d/b/a LE-1, a California Limited Partnership, Petitioner, v. WILLIAM B. TROWER, as Successor Personal Representative of the Estate of LINDA B. WEISHEIT, Respondent. 4th District.

Civil procedure -- Discovery -- Depositions -- Former opposing counsel in pending case -- Trial court properly quashed subpoena and issued protective order to prohibit defendant from taking deposition of plaintiff's former counsel where defendant failed to allege or establish that no other means existed to obtain information sought. CENTRAL CONCRETE SUPERMIX, INC., Petitioner, v. JOSE A. “PEPE” CANCIO, SR., Respondent. 3rd District.

Contracts -- Limitation of actions -- Action for breach of contract filed against estate of plaintiffs' deceased aunt and uncle alleging entitlement to “incentive money” which was initially supposed to be given to the plaintiffs for each year of college they completed pursuant to incentive program initiated by the deceased, but which was never distributed and which plaintiffs assumed was being kept under loan-back provision which stated that plaintiffs could loan the funds back to the deceased to accrue 10% interest, compounded monthly, that plaintiffs could then collect at their discretion -- No error in entering final summary judgment in favor of defendant estate -- For each installment of incentive money, the right to obtain it vested when each plaintiff completed a year of college, and thus the statute of limitations began to run when each installment was due -- Because plaintiffs did not bring action against estate until more than five years after they had each completed their last year of college, their actions were barred by the statute of limitations -- Court rejects argument that statute of limitations would begin to run only if plaintiffs' demands for payment were denied -- Lend-back provision of contract required plaintiffs to communicate their election of the provision to the deceased -- Because neither plaintiff communicated their election of the lend-back provision the provision was not invoked -- Even assuming lend-back provision had been triggered, contract ended one year after each plaintiff's respective graduation. JOHN P. WOODWARD, and ROBERT C. WOODWARD, Appellants, v. TIMOTHY J. MORELL, in his capacity as Personal Representative of THE ESTATE OF MILDRED W. OLSON, Appellee. 4th District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Child custody -- Modification -- Change in circumstances -- Magistrate's report and recommendation -- Former husband's modification petition seeking change in parental responsibility and time-sharing based, in part, on incidents involving former wife and her boyfriend -- Evidence supported magistrate's finding that there had been a substantial change in circumstances based on former wife's behaviors, her relationship with her boyfriend, and removal of children from former wife's “temporary care” during a dependency case -- Evidence supported magistrate's conclusion that, while removal of children from former wife during dependency proceedings was temporary, a substantial change in circumstances had occurred based on former wife's volatile relationship with her boyfriend which continued beyond the conclusion of dependency proceedings -- Trial court erred as a matter of law in concluding that no substantial change in circumstances had occurred and in granting wife's exceptions to magistrate's report on that basis -- Remand with directions to enter order adopting report and recommendations of magistrate. P.D.V-G., Appellant, v. B.A.V-G., Appellee. 2nd District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Injunctions -- Freezing accounts -- Trial court abused its discretion by exceeding the scope of wife's requested relief for a freeze of marital accounts when it ordered husband's individual bank accounts to be placed in both parties' names -- Issue was not tried by consent. AJAY KUMAR DODDAPANENI, Appellant, v. CANDACE ELAINE DODDAPANENI, Appellee. 5th District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Magistrates -- Report and recommendations -- Exceptions -- Trial court abused its discretion by summarily denying former wife's exceptions to magistrate's report and recommendations based upon wife's failure to file transcript of hearing before the magistrate within 45 days allotted and ordered by court -- Hearing on exceptions is mandatory, and transcript is required only “if necessary for the court's review” -- Where exceptions raise pure issues of law, such as whether magistrate's report and recommendations improperly modified parties' property rights as previously determined by final judgment of dissolution, transcript would not be necessary -- Remand for trial court to hold hearing and consider exceptions on the merits. ROSEMITA JEAN, Appellant, v. JOSUE JEAN, Appellee. 2nd District.

Insurance -- Coverage -- Venue -- Forum selection clause -- Ambiguity -- Trial court erred in transferring action to Miami-Dade County where automobile insurer has its headquarters based on determination that policy's forum selection clause, which stated that any legal action against insurer to determine coverage under the policy “shall be filed and maintained in the county where the policy was issued,” mandated exclusive venue in that county -- Forum selection clause in policy is reasonably interpreted as not restricting venue to Miami-Dade County where policy failed to define “issued” and contained no terms expressly mandating venue exclusively in Miami-Dade County. THOMAS ROBLES, Appellant, v. UNITED AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellee. 1st District.

Insurance -- Homeowners -- Appraisal -- Trial court did not err in determining that policy's appraisal provision clearly and unambiguously applied to claim by insured's assignee for water mitigation services -- Policy provided that either party could demand appraisal to resolve “disagreement regarding the amount of the covered loss,” and it was undisputed that water mitigation services performed by assignee were part of the amount of the covered loss. EXPRESS DAMAGE RESTORATION, LLC, etc., Appellant, v. CITIZENS PROPERTY INSURANCE CORPORATION, Appellee. 3rd District.

Insurance -- Homeowners -- Preferred Contractor Endorsement -- Where insurer elected to repair hurricane damage to insured home under Preferred Contractor Endorsement, and insured failed to provide a compliant sworn proof of loss and completed his own repairs to home, thereby preventing insurer from completing repairs under Preferred Contractor Endorsement, trial court erred in entering judgment requiring insurer to pay appraisal amount -- Insured breached policy by failing to fulfill post-loss obligations and hiring his own contractor to perform repairs. PEOPLE'S TRUST INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellant, v. ALEJANDRO AMARO, Appellee. 3rd District.

Mortgage foreclosure -- Relief from judgment -- Void judgment -- Foreclosure judgment in favor of junior mortgagee was properly found to be void as to senior mortgagee whose mortgage had been recorded before that of junior mortgagee -- Trial court erred in finding that motion to vacate judgment was not timely filed, as party may move to vacate void judgment at any time -- However, order denying motion to vacate judgment is affirmed, as section 702.036, Florida Statute, barred court from vacating judgment where vacation of judgment would adversely impact quality and character of title of property which had been purchased by third parties after foreclosure sale. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A., Appellant, v. CHI PENG TAN, BANK OF AMERICA, N.A., as assignee of FIRST MAGNUS FINANCIAL CORPORATION, MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATION SYSTEMS, INC., Acting solely as Nominee for FIRST MAGNUS FINANCIAL CORPORATION, an Arizona Corporation, SCHINDLER ELEVATOR CORPORATION, SOUTHERN CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC., PRECISION U.S.A., INC., PARK TOWER ASSOCIATION, INC., NISSIM SHANI and MICHELE SHANI, Appellees. 4th District.

Torts -- Automobile accident -- Comparative negligence -- Summary judgment -- Appeals -- Mootness -- Action brought against plaintiffs' insurer to recover damages stemming from two separate rear-end collisions involving plaintiffs within a two-week period -- Argument that trial court erred by not granting plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment on issues of liability and plaintiff driver's comparative negligence in causing the accidents is moot where issues were tried before a jury, and evidence authorized jury's verdict -- Argument that evidence was insufficient to allow jury to apportion negligence to plaintiff driver for failing to mitigate his business losses and his pain was not preserved for appeal where plaintiffs failed to move for a directed verdict on issue at close of evidence at trial -- Even if trial court improperly allowed mitigation factors to enter comparative negligence equation, result appears to be harmless where jury's apportionment of negligence to plaintiff driver can be attributed to evidence that plaintiff driver helped cause rear-end collisions by driving forward then suddenly stopping his vehicle. ROY STRICKLAND and KATHRYN STRICKLAND, Appellants, v. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY, a foreign corporation, Appellee. 1st District.

Torts -- Automobile accident -- Rear end collision -- Successor judge who did not preside over trial erred in granting directed verdict in favor of defendant where there was competent substantial evidence to support jury's verdict that defendant was negligent and to support jury's rejection of defendant's defense that he unexpectedly lost consciousness or experienced syncope prior to collision. KAREN HERNANDEZ, etc., Appellants, v. SHULI ANDREW MISHALI, Appellee. 3rd District.

Torts -- Discovery -- Plaintiff failed to meet his burden to establish reversible error in trial court's order granting defendant's motion for protective order and denying plaintiff's motion to compel depositions where plaintiff has failed to provide transcript of hearing during which discovery motions were discussed -- Summary judgment -- Claim that trial court erred in denying plaintiff's motion to continue summary judgment hearing was not preserved for appellate review where plaintiff never obtained an order denying his motion to continue hearing. HENRY TIEN, Appellant, v. AKERMAN LLP (and the terminated AKERMAN, SENTERFITT & EIDSON, P.A.), Appellees. 3rd District.

Torts -- False arrest -- Municipal corporations -- Trial court properly entered summary judgment for defendant city on claim of false arrest where city police officers had probable cause to arrest plaintiff for obstruction without violence -- Where plaintiff had been called by police to pick up her son who was being detained for trespassing at a theater, after arriving at scene plaintiff continued to videotape and audiotape officers after being told to stop and obstructed officers' investigation and processing of her son's detention, there was probable cause for her arrest for obstruction without violence. SHARRON TASHA FORD, Appellant, v. CITY OF BOYNTON BEACH, a Florida municipal corporation, Appellee. 4th District.

Torts -- Jurors -- Challenge -- Trial court erred in denying plaintiff's motion to excuse prospective juror who specifically stated that his previous negative experience with a similar type of claim in an accident involving juror's son made it difficult for juror to remain impartial in his evaluation of facts and evidence in plaintiff's case -- Juror's later answer that he would keep an open mind because “every case is different” was not sufficient to rehabilitate juror -- New trial required where plaintiff was forced to use peremptory challenge against this prospective juror and trial court later denied plaintiff's request for additional peremptory challenge of juror over whom plaintiff expressed concern. ALEJANDRA RIVAS, Appellant, v. ALICIA SANDOVAL, Appellee. 3rd District.

Torts -- Negligence -- Excessive use of force -- Duty of care -- Amendment of complaint -- Appeals -- Action alleging that detention officers used excessive force during incident in which plaintiff was restrained and seriously injured after inmate medical services failed to conduct a mental evaluation -- Trial court erred in dismissing negligence counts against sheriff -- Plaintiff alleged an independent, common law duty of reasonable care by sheriff and the detention officers charged with his supervision -- Although plaintiff's negligence count did reference sheriff's use of force policy which does not create an independent duty of care, plaintiff's complaint stated a cause of action against sheriff for negligently failing to fulfill its independent duty of care because the detention officers allegedly used excessive force -- Sovereign immunity does not bar action against sheriff where allegations appear to be regarding sheriff's negligence in performance of established duties and failure to follow the policies already established -- These are operational level activities for which sheriff is not immune from suit -- No error in dismissing negligence claims against inmate medical services which alleged that inmate medical services had breached duties imposed upon it through its contract with the sheriff -- Contract clearly provides that it creates no right or cause of action to a third party -- Plaintiff waived any claim that he was entitled to amend his complaint for a third time because he failed to request leave to amend before or after court dismissed the complaint. CHARLES WILLIAMS, Appellant, v. GREGORY TONY, as Sheriff of Broward County Florida, ARMOR CORRECTIONAL HEALTH SERVICES, INC., and WANDA LOWES, R.N., Appellees. 4th District.

Torts -- Product liability -- Restaurants -- Service of contaminated food -- Action alleging that raw oysters served by defendant was legal cause of plaintiff's Guillain-Barré Syndrome -- Trial court erred in granting defendant's posttrial motion for entry of judgment in accordance with defendant's motion for directed verdict, which had been filed in a prior trial that had resulted in a deadlocked jury, based on determination that plaintiff's expert's testimony was based on impermissible inference stacking -- Defendant was required to move for directed verdict during second trial where parties did not stipulate that defendant's motion for directed verdict made during the prior trial would carry over to the second trial -- Additionally, motion for directed verdict made in prior trial could not apply to second trial where inferences identified by defendant in its motion in limine, which served as the premise for the motion for directed verdict, were stipulated facts in second trial -- While the legal theory might have been the same, the evidence upon which it would have been based was different -- Even if trial court could have considered posttrial motion for judgment in accordance with the motion for directed verdict, the trial court misapplied law with regard to directed verdicts -- Trial court's findings improperly evaluated testimony in favor of the moving party rather than the nonmoving party, and either disregarded conflicts in the evidence or resolved them in favor of defendant -- There was no stacking of inferences in this case -- Singular inference made by plaintiff's expert was the ultimate conclusion that GI infection, the stipulated cause of which was defendant's defective food, caused plaintiff's GBS -- Because plaintiff's expert did not simply provide a summary conclusion without a factual basis, jury was entitled to determine that the defective food was the legal cause of plaintiff's GBS. ANGEL MARTINEZ and MARIA ELENA MARTINEZ, Appellants, v. LOBSTER HAVEN, LLC, Appellee. 2nd District.

Wrongful death -- Nursing homes -- Arbitration -- Selection of arbitrator -- Appeals -- Certiorari -- Petition seeking review of order compelling plaintiff to select a nominating arbitrator to act along with defendant's chosen nominating arbitrator for the single purpose of selecting a sole arbitrator in plaintiff's action against defendant -- Trial court departed from essential requirement of the law in rewriting parties' agreement in defendant's favor by allowing defendant to choose a nominator despite having forfeited its right to do so by missing the express deadline set forth in its own residency agreement -- Trial court's conclusion that plaintiff's arbitrator selection was somehow impermissible because it was transmitted near the end of the business day on the day it was due is not supported by the agreement or any legal authority -- Relief granted by trial court was not appropriate under either section 682.031 or 682.04 where defendant presented no good cause to rewrite agreement, and parties' chosen method of appointing arbitrators did not fail -- Because plaintiff will be able to challenge eventual arbitration award on appeal, it cannot establish irreparable harm -- Petition denied. THE ESTATE OF GRACE QUINN, by and through BARBARA ECK, Personal Representative, Petitioner, v. CCRC OPCO FREEDOM SQUARE LLC; BKD TWENTY-ONE MANAGEMENT; BROOKDALE SENIOR LIVING, INC.; and SHELLY CRADDOCK, ADMINISTRATOR, (AS TO THE INN AT FREEDOM SQUARE), Respondents. 2nd District.

The Law Lady.  For more info about us, click here.  To be added to our email circulation with MUCH, MUCH more law, click here and specify whether you wish to be added to our CRIMINAL, CIVIL, or  FEDERAL Recent Decisions of Interest.

Wednesday, September 9, 2020

Torts, trespass, premises liability, dissolution, and Chicken Mole Poblano, nasturtium and heirloom cucumber salad


 Appeals -- Stay -- Automatic bankruptcy stay -- Appellate panel is bound by court's prior decision in Shop in the Grove, Ltd. v. Union Federal Savings and Loan Ass'n of Miami, 425 So. 2d 1138 (Fla. 3d DCA 1982), which held that bankruptcy automatic stay provision is inapplicable in appellate court where the debtor, who is the defendant below and who has filed for federal bankruptcy protection, is the appellant, but panel suggests that court should revisit and recede from that decision. NATIONAL MEDICAL IMAGING, LLC, et al., Appellants, v. LYON FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC., etc., Appellee. 3rd District.

Child custody -- Appeals -- Order approving report and recommendation of general magistrate regarding time-sharing and parenting plan affirmed -- Appellate review is limited to errors on face of order where no exceptions to report and recommendation were filed. MELISSA LYNN MURPHY, Appellant, v. LACY AUSTIN RAY HUTCHENS, Appellee. 5th District.

Civil procedure -- Setting of action for trial -- Failure to strictly comply with rule 1.440 -- Final judgment reversed where matter was tried prematurely and not properly noticed for trial. BENJAMIN CHANCEY AND ANGELIA CHANCEY, Appellants, v. MICHAEL YOUNG AND MARION COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, Appellees. 5th District.

Contracts -- Employment -- Termination/nonrenewal -- Action brought against employer claiming breach of contract and covenant of good faith, reformation, and negligent misrepresentation stemming from the employer's decision to not renew employee's contract after expiration of the initial term and place employee on administrative leave without following procedures outlined in termination provision of contract -- No error in entering summary judgment in favor of employer on breach of contract claim -- Administrative leave is not the same as termination, and employer's summary judgment evidence established that employee was placed on administrative leave, where he remained with full pay and benefits, until the agreement expired -- Although employee was relieved of his duties, fact remains that employee was not terminated during the term of the agreement and, as such, employer was not required to follow termination provision of contract when it declined to renew -- Additionally, other provisions of contract state that expiration is not dismissal or termination which would trigger contract's termination provision -- Trial court's interpretation of contract was reasonable and gave effect to the entire agreement -- Because there is no breach of contract claim, claim that employer breached the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing necessarily fails -- No error in entering summary judgment in favor of employer on reformation claim where employee showed no wrongful or inequitable conduct by employer, and employee's evidence conclusively contradicted his claim of mistake -- Trial court's apparent erroneous ruling that the statute of frauds barred reformation claim does not warrant reversal because summary judgment was otherwise appropriate -- No error in entering summary judgment in favor of employer on claim of negligent misrepresentation -- Contract was not ambiguous and alleged misrepresentations made to employee reflected contract's language -- Although trial court adopted employer's proposed order verbatim, including erroneous legal conclusion that statute of frauds prohibited reformation claim, circumstances of the case do not create an appearance that the trial court failed to exercise independent judgment. DARREN WHITE, Appellant, v. FORT MYERS BEACH FIRE CONTROL DISTRICT, Appellee. 2nd District.

Contracts -- Jurisdiction -- Non-residents -- Action by Florida company against Puerto Rican company for breach of contract for plaintiff to install glass tiles in pools being constructed by defendant in Puerto Rico -- Trial court erred in denying motion to dismiss where plaintiff failed to establish that defendant had sufficient minimum contacts with Florida to satisfy due process requirements for personal jurisdiction over defendant -- Specific jurisdiction provision of long-arm statute was satisfied by allegation that defendant breached contract in Florida by failing to make payments in Florida as required by contract -- Substantial services under contract were performed in Puerto Rico, not Florida, and defendant did not purposefully avail itself of privilege of conducting business activities in Florida, and did not establish minimum contacts with Florida. JOHNNY'S POOL SUPER CENTER, INC., Appellant, v. FOREVERPOOLS CARIBBEAN, LLC, Appellee. 3rd District.

Contracts -- Sale of real property -- Option to purchase -- Specific performance -- Trial court did not err in declining to grant specific performance of an option to repurchase certain real property where, although option holder furnished notice of intent to exercise the option as authorized under original purchase contract, trial court found a dearth of proof that option holder stood ready, willing, and able to tender payment, along with a lack of compliance with certain contractually stipulated terms -- An option holder must strictly comply with the applicable provisions of the contract, necessarily accepting the terms of the option unqualifiedly. LUPETTO, INC., Appellant, v. SOUTH BAY DEVELOPERS GROUP, LLC, etc., et al., Appellees. 3rd District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Alimony -- Permanent alimony award reversed where, without explanation, the award falls short of former wife's basic monthly expenses while leaving former husband with a substantial surplus. JOY TRACHTMAN TORDINI N/K/A JOY TRACHTMAN, Appellant, v. RAPHAEL JOSEPH TORDINI, Appellee. 5th District.

Estates -- Attorney's fees -- Personal representative's counsel -- Substantial competent evidence supported contractual attorney's fees awarded for administration of the estate, and there were no allegations of bad faith or overcharging. QUANISHA HARRIS, Appellant, v. IN RE: ESTATE OF WILLIE HARRIS, Appellee. 3rd District.

Insurance -- Homeowners -- Bad faith -- Failure to attempt in good faith to settle claim -- Trial court erred in entering summary judgment for insurer in insureds' bad faith action on ground that insurer cured a Civil Remedy Notice of Insurer's Violations by invoking the appraisal process before the CRN was filed and paying the appraisal award more than sixty days after the CRN was filed -- CRN is not required to contain a specific amount sought to cure alleged bad faith. PATTI FORTUNE and JEREMY DOMIN, Appellants, v. FIRST PROTECTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY d/b/a FRONTLINE INSURANCE, Appellee. 2nd District.

Insurance -- Third-party beneficiaries -- Language of the policy of insurance clearly reflects that plaintiff was not intended to primarily and directly benefit from the policy where policy expressly stated that it was only between the named insured and the insurer, and that there was no contract of insurance between insurer and plaintiff. PAMELA GOINS, Appellant, v. PRAETORIAN INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellee. 5th District.

Mortgage foreclosure -- Judges -- Disqualification -- Adverse rulings -- Petition for prohibition seeking review of order denying disqualification of judge based on claim that judge discounted petitioner's credibility by ordering sequestration of rents despite petitioner's affidavit that petitioner lacked a tenant -- Petition is denied where record shows that challenged action did not stem from disqualifying personal bias or prejudice toward petitioner. NIDIA N. MAGARINO, Petitioner, v. THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON, etc., Respondent. 3rd District. Probate rules -- Amendments -- Petition to determine capacity -- Designation of health care surrogates or other advance directives -- Petition for appointment of guardian of an incapacitated person -- Petitioner required to state whether they have knowledge or belief that there are other possible alternatives to guardianship -- Guardian advocate -- Petitioner required to state whether they have knowledge that person with developmental disability has executed a designation of health care surrogate -- Expedited judicial intervention concerning medical treatment procedures -- Forms -- Adoption of new rules containing standardized forms to reduce costs and create uniformity statewide. IN RE: AMENDMENTS TO THE FLORIDA PROBATE RULES -- GUARDIANSHIP. Supreme Court of Florida.

Real property -- Homestead -- Insurance -- Assignment of post-loss benefits -- Question certified: Does Article X, section 4(c) of the Florida Constitution allow the owner of homestead property, joined by the spouse if married, to assign post-loss insurance benefits to a third-party contractor contracted to make repairs to the homestead property?. LANDMARK CONSTRUCTION INC. OF CENTRAL FLORIDA, AS ASSIGNEE OF CARMELO GONZALEZ AND VICTORIA GONZALEZ, Appellant, v. ANCHOR PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellee. 5th District.

 

Replevin -- Unclean hands -- Summary judgment -- Action by lender seeking to obtain mobile home from successor in interest to foreclosed property on which the mobile was located -- Trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of property owner based on unclean hands defense alleging that lender had made material misrepresentations to bankruptcy court concerning the value of, and equity in, the mobile home in order to maintain control of the asset -- Property owner failed to establish that it was injured as a result of lender's alleged misconduct where bankruptcy documents did not support property owner's position that misconduct caused its predecessor in interest to file responsive pleadings in bankruptcy case -- Even assuming that predecessor in interest's expenditure of time and resources could be relied upon to show an injury to property owner, it is clear from the record that no such expenditure was shown. 21ST MORTGAGE CORPORATION, Appellant, v. TSE PLANTATION, LLC, MERI L. HARRELL, CURTIS R. HARRELL, et al., Appellees. 1st District.

 

Rules of Supreme Court Relating to Admissions to the Bar and Rules Regulating the Florida Bar -- Amendments -- Court declines to adopt proposed emergency rules to provide for admission to the Florida Bar without examination, followed by a supervised practice requirement, of applicants who otherwise qualify for admission based upon graduation from an ABA-accredited law school and demonstration of good moral character to aid registrants for the July 2020 Florida General Bar Examination who have been severely impacted by the delays in administering the examination. IN RE: PETITION TO AMEND THE RULES OF THE SUPREME COURT RELATING TO ADMISSIONS TO THE BAR AND THE RULES REGULATING THE FLORIDA BAR. Supreme Court of Florida.

 

Rules Regulating Florida Bar -- Amendments -- Conditionally admitted members -- Members admitted to Bar pursuant to consent agreement no longer treated as a separate class of “Conditionally Admitted Members” that are subject to term of probation -- Such members to be treated as any other members of Bar in good standing, except for the added terms of the consent agreement. IN RE: AMENDMENTS TO RULE REGULATING THE FLORIDA BAR -- RULE 1-3.2(b). Supreme Court of Florida.

 

Torts -- Civil theft -- Default -- Damages -- Unliquidated damages -- Default entered for failure to answer complaint in an action alleging civil theft based on defendant's failure to compensate plaintiff with funds received from selling plaintiff's personal items -- Trial court erred in entering final judgment awarding plaintiff unliquidated damages without notice and an opportunity to be heard -- Complaint seeking a specified amount of damages, which was based upon plaintiff's attached list of values that she placed on the respective items of personal property stolen, was a claim for unliquidated damages that did not convert or become a liquidated damage claim by virtue of the later default entered against defendant -- Court recedes from precedent which held that unliquidated damages are converted to liquidated damages when a plaintiff alleges in its complaint that it was damaged in a sum certain and defendant is later defaulted for failing to answer the complaint. ANTHONY J. CIOTTI, AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF ANTHONY G. CIOTTI, Appellant, v. NANCI HUBSCH, Appellee. 5th District.

 

Torts -- Civil theft -- Remedies -- Attorney's fees -- Trial court erred in denying defendants' motion for attorney's fees pursuant to section 772.11 because record shows that plaintiff's civil theft claims were without substantial fact or legal support -- Plaintiff's claims of civil theft were by definition without any factual evidentiary support where trial court had granted directed verdict in favor of defendants on grounds that there was no showing of criminal intent, which is an essential element of a civil theft claim. ISLAND TRAVEL & TOURS LTD. CO., a Florida Corporation, WILLIAM J. HAUF, an individual, ISMAEL O. SENE, an individual, and DANNY LOONEY, an individual, Appellants, v. MYR INDEPENDENT, INC., etc., Appellee. 3rd District.

 

Torts -- Malicious prosecution -- False arrest -- Absolute immunity -- State attorneys -- Appeals -- Certiorari -- Complaint against assistant state attorney and state attorney stemming from ASA's securing of a material witness warrant for plaintiff's arrest allegedly based on statements ASA knew to be false, and ASA's unsuccessful argument for plaintiff's continued detention -- Discussion of a prosecutor's entitlement to absolute immunity -- Trial court erred in denying ASA and SA's motions to dismiss based on absolute immunity where trial court based its analysis on whether ASA was acting in good faith -- In determining absolute immunity, courts must look to the nature of the function performed, not the identity of the actor who performed it -- Once it is determined that the challenged conduct involves a function covered by absolute immunity, the actor is shielded from liability for damages regardless of the wrongfulness of his motive or the degree of injury caused -- ASA's action in filing the motion for a material witness warrant and advocating for her continued detention were done in the course of an ongoing prosecution and, regardless of ASA's motives, he continued to function as an advocate and his actions were not administrative in nature. SYED MUNAWWAR QADRI, ESQUIRE, AND ARAMIS AYALA, STATE ATTORNEY, NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, ORANGE COUNTY, FLORIDA, Petitioners, v. SANDRA MARIE RIVERA-MERCADO, Respondent. 5th District.

 

Torts -- Premises liability -- Business invitee -- Trip and fall -- Depression in parking lot -- Open and obvious danger -- Trial court erred in entering summary judgment in favor of defendants based on conclusion that plaintiff was injured as a result of an open obvious danger -- Based on summary judgment record, a jury could conclude that depression in pavement was not so open and obvious that defendants could reasonably expect that it would be discovered by an invitee where plaintiff stated that the depression blended into the parking lot, and picture of depression depicted a man-made hole that was the same color as the surrounding asphalt and contained dried leaves -- Moreover, even when a dangerous condition is open and obvious, the occupier of the premises is not excused from its duties to protect and warn invitees if it reasonably should anticipate that the condition poses an unreasonable risk of harm to invitee notwithstanding the obvious nature of the condition -- A jury could conclude that defendants reasonably should have anticipated that an invitee negotiating the parking lot to visit defendant's establishment, which resembled an enormous ice cream cone, would be distracted by its striking appearance and by the need to watch for approaching vehicles. TRACY GREENE and JOSHUA GREENE, Appellants, v. TWISTEE TREAT USA, LLC; MISSION BELL, S.C., LLC; and KIMCO REALTY CORPORATION, Appellees. 2nd District.

 

Torts -- Trespass -- Homeowner's action against neighbor that allegedly hired construction company to trespass upon homeowner's property and remove and destroy sedimentary rock foundation beneath homeowner's fence -- Counterclaims and third-party claims seeking injunctive relief and damages -- Competent, substantial evidence supported judgment in favor of homeowner and award of damages -- No error in pretrial orders dismissing portions of neighbor's second amended third-party complaint and second and third amended counterclaims. MARSHALL IVES, Appellant, v. TATE GETTINGER and ANAMARIA GETTINGER, and ALEX FENCES, INC., Appellees. 3rd District.

 

 The Law Lady.  For more info about us, click here.  To be added to our email circulation with MUCH, MUCH more law, click here and specify whether you wish to be added to our CRIMINAL, CIVIL, or  FEDERAL Recent Decisions of Interest.

Wednesday, August 19, 2020

We're back blogging with more Recent Decisions of Interest in Dissolution, Attorney's Fees etc. and Garlic White Pizza with Chanterelles and Arugula

I want to apologize to all for being so busy with work and our Recent Decisions of Interest Newsletters that have tripled over the last 6 months.  But I am back!  Stay healthy and safe everyone.


Attorney's fees -- Civil rights -- Prevailing party -- Award of prevailing party attorney's fees and expenses to plaintiff under 42 U.S.C. section 1988 must be vacated and remanded for additional proceedings where jury awarded only nominal damages for defendant's violation of plaintiff's Fourth Amendment right to be free from illegal seizure and district court in determining reasonableness of a fee award misapplied the law in measuring significance of the substantive issue on which plaintiff prevailed or public purpose served by totaling up number of times that Gray II, which was decided in plaintiff's favor, had been cited -- It was error of law for district court to conclude that simply because Gray II had been cited more than fifty times during a two-year period, the substantive issue on which plaintiff prevailed must be significant and public purpose served by her victory must be substantial -- When citation-counting is used as a method for assessing the significance of a decision in plaintiff's favor, citation of the decision for humdrum, non-controversial, or long-established points of law do not matter and must not be included in the tabulation -- On remand, district court to decide whether plaintiff is entitled to award of attorney's fees and expenses, even though she recovered only nominal damages; and if so, whether she is entitled to enhancement for delay in payment of expenses and for delay in payment of attorney's fees; and if so, how much -- Calculation errors to be avoided on remand noted
LAQUARIUS GRAY, a minor, by and through her mother and next friend, Toniko L. Alexander, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. ANTONIO BOSTIC, individually and in his official capacity as Deputy Sheriff for Tuscaloosa County, AL, Defendant-Appellant, EDMUND SEXTON, etc., et al., Defendants. 11th Circuit.

Elections -- Campaign financing -- Excess spending subsidy -- Injunctions -- Candidate for Republican Party for Governor of State of Florida, who is not participating in Florida system of public campaign financing, moved to preliminarily enjoin enforcement of provision of Florida Election Campaign Financing Act, which provides participating candidates with a subsidy to spend on their campaigns when a nonparticipating opponent spends in excess of statutory expenditure limit or $2 for each registered Florida voter -- Plaintiff is entitled to preliminary injunction enjoining State from releasing funds to opposing candidate under excess spending provision because he is likely to succeed on merits of First and Fourteenth Amendment claim that excess spending subsidy severely burdens his constitutional rights to spend unlimited sums of personal funds and private donations in furtherance of his campaign, burden on his right to free speech is irreparable, and, as district court concluded, balance of harms and public interest do not counsel against an injunction -- Under Davis v. Federal Election Commission, excess spending subsidy imposes substantial burden on nonparticipating candidate's right of free speech and is thus subject to strict scrutiny, which requires that Florida justify the subsidy by establishing that it furthers a compelling state interest -- Even if subsidy furthers stated interest of Florida by encouraging participation in public financing system and indirectly preventing corruption or appearance of corruption, excess spending subsidy is not least restrictive means of furthering the anticorruption interest -- Severability -- Even if issue of severance is premature, excess spending subsidy is severable from $500 contribution limit
RICHARD L. SCOTT, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. DAWN K. ROBERTS, In Her Official Capacity as Interim Secretary of State of the State of Florida, Defendant-Appellee, IRA WILLIAM McCOLLUM, JR., Intervenor-Defendant-Appellee. 11th Circuit.

Contracts -- Third-party beneficiaries -- Action by homeowners association seeking declaration of rights under crossing agreement between railroad and another homeowners association -- Trial court properly dismissed action on ground that plaintiff homeowners association is not a party to the agreement at issue and not a third-party beneficiary of the agreement -- Plaintiff is not entitled to relief as a third-party beneficiary where parties to agreement did not intend that the agreement be for the benefit of plaintiff, and agreement expressly excludes third-party beneficiaries
VENEZIA LAKES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC., Appellant, v. CSX TRANSPORTATION, INC., Appellee. 3rd District.

Counties -- Injunctions -- Trial court erred in finding that county denied property owner due process by not giving proper notice of administrative hearing on code violation citation -- Record indicates that notice of hearing was sent to owner at both his address of record with county and the address listed at the top of his request for administrative hearing -- Further, it is evident from record that owner had actual notice of hearing -- Trial court erred in granting owner's motion for temporary injunction on ground that owner had been denied due process through administrative hearing process on citation, and trial court was therefore entitled to intervene in administrative hearing process
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, Appellant, vs. KEITH WILSON, Appellee. 3rd District.

Dissolution of marriage -- Alimony -- Modification -- Jurisdiction -- Uniform Interstate Family Support Act -- Trial court had no authority to transfer Florida post-final-judgment dissolution case to foreign state in which both former spouses now reside -- Under UIFSA, Florida court has continuing exclusive jurisdiction over spousal support order throughout the existence of the support obligation -- Correct procedure under UIFSA is to register spousal support judgment in another state for enforcement there; and even after registration, foreign state must send the case back to Florida court to consider any modification order
ANA ALVAREZ SOOTIN, Appellant, vs. JOHN SOOTIN, Appellee. 3rd District. Opinion filed August 4, 2010.

Guardianship -- Trial court abused discretion in appointing ward's son-in-law as her plenary guardian where ward had executed a declaration naming her three daughters as preneed guardians -- There was insufficient evidence to rebut the statutory presumption that the designated preneed guardian is entitled to serve as guardian
MARIANNE MAGILL ACUNA & MARILYN MAGILL, Appellants, vs. JACK DRESNER, ET AL., Appellees. 3rd District.

Jurisdiction -- Service of process -- Substitute service -- Service of process was defective where process server failed to note time of service on copy of complaint delivered to the person served -- Requirement to note time on copy of complaint is statutory requirement of service, and strict compliance with statutory requirements of service is mandated -- Second service of process while appeal was pending did not render appeal moot
JOSE E. VIDAL, Appellant, v. SUNTRUST BANK, Appellee. 4th District.

Receiverships -- Ex parte -- Mortgage foreclosure -- Error to appoint receiver for property involved in mortgage foreclosure action without providing notice and opportunity to be heard where mortgagee failed to establish that ex parte receivership was necessary to avoid immediate irreparable harm to mortgaged property or that giving notice and holding a hearing would accelerate or precipitate any injury -- Although loan documents contained provision for appointment of receiver as matter of right and without notice if foreclosure proceedings were instituted, this alone is not dispositive of whether to grant ex parte receivership and provisions of rule 1.610 are not thereby bypassed -- Argument that ex parte receivership was necessary to assist in sale of property rejected -- Argument that ex parte receivership was appropriate because mortgage documents contained assignment of rents provision which provided for appointment of receiver in that context was not raised as basis for appointing receiver; and, moreover, mortgagee did not present verified allegation that any rents were actually being collected on the property or that any such rents were being dissipated -- Trial court also failed to enter appropriate ex parte order where order did not contain any factual findings
JOHN R. DeSILVA, Appellant, v. FIRST COMMUNITY BANK OF AMERICA, a Federal Stock Savings Bank, Appellee. 2nd District.

Title insurance -- Trial court properly determined that title insurance company was not liable for title insurance agency's misappropriation of plaintiffs' escrow deposits for the purchase of condominium units where escrow deposits were received by agency in its limited capacity as escrow agency for developer, and the escrow deposits were not received in connection with a transaction involving the issuance of title insurance binders, commitments, policies of title insurance, or guarantees of title -- Escrow deposits did not constitute funds held in trust pursuant to section 626.8473, Florida Statutes
BERNARD WINKLER, ET AL., Appellants, vs. LAWYERS TITLE INSURANCE CORP., ETC., Appellee. 3rd District.

Torts -- Automobile accident -- Damages -- New trial is required where plaintiff's counsel made an improper appeal to passion and sympathy of jury in opening statement, improperly convinced trial judge to limit defense counsel's cross-examination of plaintiff's expert, improperly attacked character of main defense expert during cross-examination, and made improper and prejudicial closing argument
DANIEL GILBERT ANDREW CHIN, Appellant, v. WILLIAM ROGER CAIAFFA, Appellee. 3rd District.

Torts -- Damages -- Future medical expenses -- Abuse of discretion to deny defendants' motion for new trial and motion for remittitur where there was no competent substantial evidence presented at trial that plaintiff was reasonably certain to need future medical treatment -- Remand for new trial or, in the alternative, entry of amended final judgment remitting award for future medical expenses -- Past medical expenses -- Setoff -- Error to fail to determine and apply setoff for personal injury protection benefits to award of past damages
ALICIA E. MONTESINOS AND HUGHETTE ESQUIVEL, Appellants, vs. JAVIER ZAPATA, Appellee. 3rd District.

Torts -- Nuisance -- No error in dismissing with prejudice complaint in which plaintiff sought to recover damages to property allegedly caused by overhanging branches and roots of neighbor's trees encroaching on her property and damages resulting from plaintiff's removal of portions of neighbor's tree intruding on her property
VIRGINIA T. SCOTT, Appellant, v. JULIE L. McCARTY, M.D., Appellee. 4th District.

 

The Law Lady.  For more info about us, click here.  To be added to our email circulation with MUCH, MUCH more law, click here and specify whether you wish to be added to our CRIMINAL, CIVIL, or  FEDERAL Recent Decisions of Interest.